As a young girl, I was drawn to darker subjects. I was the kind of child who watched Child’s Play at 4 and then casually asked my mom, “Is it bad to throw your mommy out the window?” I had this tendency to scowl in photographs, which was blamed on shyness by adults who didn’t want to admit I was simply weird.
But I wasn’t drawn to darkness because I was sad; I was drawn to it because I was bored. Even at 9, the sanitized world of childhood felt insultingly shallow: pink tutus, playdates with girls perfectly content with Webkinz and friendship bracelets. Maybe it was a desire to be older—or just different—to prove there was more to me to offer.
By seventh grade, I found a new guiding light in my pursuit of artificial sad girl-dom: Skins, a British teen drama about drugs and despair. It was less a TV show and more a portal opening to another dimension. I tried the character Effy Stonem’s style on for size: a haircut mimicking her choppy allure, blue eyeliner smudged into an approximation of her edgy detachment. I practiced holding a pen between my fingers like a cigarette, studying the elegant drape of her hand. I started to believe that her tragedy was glamorous and that sadness makes you visible. Suffering, I thought, was a kind of personality I could adopt. And for someone desperate to have one, I was hooked.
Thirteen, a 2003 teen drama, was even more impactful on my quest for an identity. It was a movie my older sister had forbidden me to watch until I myself was 13, as if being the same age as the characters would somehow prepare me. Evie and Tracy, played by the preternaturally cool Nikki Reed (who also cowrote the film, based on her own life) and Evan Rachel Wood, seemed impossibly older, rawer, and more dangerous than their years, bending time and age the way adolescence often does. After diving into Evie and Tracy’s universe and adopting their mannerisms, style, and disdain for society for a season, I moved on to the classic sad girl ingenues in Girl, Interrupted, and The Virgin Suicides.
For me, these weren’t just movies. They were manuals for self-destruction, rich with aestheticized despair. Effy Stonem, Evie and Tracy, the Lisbon sisters of the Virgin Suicides—they weren’t just sad. They owned sadness. It was their currency. Their armor. I wanted to be studied. I wanted boys to write songs about my depth and melancholy or at the very least stand outside my house holding up a boombox blasting “Iris” by the Goo Goo Dolls. I wasn’t actually depressed yet, but I was determined to play it.